U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

Improving calibration of forensic glass comparisons by considering uncertainty in feature-based elemental data

NCJ Number
Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems Volume: 217 Dated: October 2021
Date Published
October 2021
Daniel Ramos; Juan Maroñas; Jose Almirall

This article proposes models that outperform previously proposed feature-based likelihood ratio (LR) models by improving the calibration of the computed LRs.


The computation of likelihood ratios (LR) to measure the weight of forensic glass evidence with LA-ICP-MS data directly in the feature space without computing any kind of score as an intermediate step is a complex problem. A probabilistic two-level modeling of the within-source and between-source variability of the glass samples is needed in order to compare the elemental profiles measured from glass recovered from a suspect or a crime scene and compared to glass samples of a known source of origin. Calibration of the likelihood ratios generated using previously reported models is essential to the realistic reporting of the value of the glass evidence comparisons. The current proposal assumes that the within-source variability is heavy-tailed, in order to incorporate uncertainty when the available data is scarce, as typically happens in forensic glass comparison. Moreover, the current proposal addresses the complexity of the between-source variability by the use of probabilistic machine learning algorithms, namely a variational autoencoder and a warped Gaussian mixture. The results show that the overall performance of the likelihood ratios generated by the proposed model is superior to classical approaches, and that this improvement is due to a dramatic improvement in the calibration despite some loss in discriminating power. Moreover, the robustness of the calibration of this proposal is remarkable. (publisher abstract modified)

Date Created: October 6, 2021