Criminology: An Interdisciplinary Journal Volume: 53 Issue: 1 Dated: 2015 Pages: 21-53
This article documents the design and implementation of a randomized controlled field experiment that evaluated the effectiveness of the following three policing tactics applied to small, high-crime places: 1) foot patrol, 2) problem-oriented policing, and 3) offender-focused policing.
Policing tactics that are proactive, focused on small places or groups of people in small places, and tailoring specific solutions to problems using analysis of local conditions seem to be effective in reducing violent crime; however, research has not yet determined which tactics are most effective when applied at hot spots. In the current study, 81 experimental places were identified from the highest violent crime areas in Philadelphia (27 areas were judged amenable to each policing tactic). Within each group of 27 areas, 20 places were randomly assigned to receive treatment and 7 places acted as controls. Offender-focused sites experienced a 42-percent reduction in all violent crime and a 50-percent reduction in violent felonies compared with their control places. Problem-oriented policing and foot patrol did not significantly reduce violent crime or violent felonies. Potential explanations of these findings are discussed in the contexts of dosage, implementation, and hot spot stability over time. (publisher abstract modified)
United States of America