U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

'You Didn't Take Lucy's Skirt Off': The Effect of Misleading Information on Omissions and Commissions in Children's Memory Reports

NCJ Number
Legal and Criminological Psychology Volume: 15 Issue: 2 Dated: September 2010 Pages: 229-241
Henry Otgaar; Ingrid Candel; Tom Smeets; Harald Merckelbach
Date Published
September 2010
13 pages
The current study explored how misleading information affects children's omissions and commissions over time.
Overall, omission and commission errors significantly decreased over time, although this pattern was more pronounced for omission errors. Younger and older children were equally likely to make omission errors, whereas commission errors were more typical for younger than for older children. Also, we found that commission errors more readily occur than omission errors. Even when children's memory reports pertain to an event in which they actively participated, misleading information may elicit omission and commission errors, with especially the latter category being very persistent over time. Fifty-nine younger (Mage=4.16) and fifty-nine older (Mage=9.44) children were instructed to remove three pieces of clothing from a puppet. Half of them were provided with false evidence that they had removed only two items, while the other half were provided with false evidence that they had removed a fourth piece of clothing. In three neutral interviews separated by 1-week intervals, children had to report which pieces of clothing they had removed. Figure, table, and references (Published Abstract)