U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

"Satan's Minions" and "True Believers": How Criminal Defense Attorneys Employ Quasi-Religious Rhetoric and What It Suggests about Lawyering Culture

NCJ Number
304815
Journal
Justice System Journal Volume: Online Dated: April 2022
Author(s)
Elizabeth Webster; Kathleen Powell; Sarah E. Lageson; Valerio Baćak
Date Published
April 2022
Annotation

We examine attorneys’ language – specifically, attorneys’ quasi-religious rhetoric – to better understand courtroom dynamics: how attorneys see themselves, their work, their colleagues, and their legal adversaries.

 

Abstract

The notion of law as sacred, and lawyers as righteous saviors, may seem anachronistic in the current context of heavy caseloads and expedited processing in the criminal justice system. Nevertheless, language reflecting these ideals still permeates defense attorneys’ descriptions of their roles, their legal practice, and their relationships to their colleagues and adversaries. In the current analysis of semi-structured interviews with 30 defense attorneys, we find that attorneys use of quasi-religious rhetoric manifests as a cultural practice that helps to establish and maintain professional identities, boundaries, and relationships. Our findings also suggest that young and novice public defenders are likely to express especially zealous views, which may compromise their efforts to collaborate within the adversarial system, as well as contribute to burnout. (Publisher Abstract Provided)

Date Published: April 1, 2022